Reality of 10% Reservation for Economically Weak: New Jumla? | Opinion by Dhruv Rathee

शेयर करें
एम्बेड करें
  • 9/01/2019 को प्रकाशित
  • Union cabinet on Monday approved 10% reservation in jobs and educational institutions for economically weak sections in general category. This will be given over and above the existing 50% reservation. In this video, I will tell you why I think this new scheme is nothing but a Jumla and a Lollipop to appease voters. The data suggests that more than 90% of general category people are eligible for being ‘Economically weak” and poor according to new criterion (based on my assumptions). So the question arises here, will the real poor people even benefit from this? What is the point of this new reservation? Ironically, people sill have to pay income tax despite being eligible under this category. Sources: www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/budget/only-76-lakh-indians-showed-income-of-over-rs-5-lakh-jaitley/article9514752.ecewww.thehindu.com/news/national/obc-creamy-layer-income-limit-raised-to-8-lakh-per-annum/article19677545.ecel
    timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/almost-every-indian-now-covered-by-one-quota-or-another/articleshow/67429441.cms
    Support my work: www.patreon.com/dhruvrathee
    ----------------------------------------------------
    For more informative videos and discussion on important Indian and world issues-
    Telegram channel to receive instant video updates: t.me/dhruvratheechannel
    Support on Patreon: www.patreon.com/dhruvrathee Subscribe: inclips.net/user/dhruvrathee
    Facebook: facebook.com/DhruvRatheePage
    Twitter: twitter.com/dhruv_rathee
    Instagram: instagram.com/dhruvrathee
    More Interviews by Dhruv Rathee: inclips.net/user/playlist?list...
    All episodes of The Dhruv Rathee Show:
    Ep 9 Black Money: inclips.net/video/UdNe4Bv8ARY/वीडियो.html
    Ep 8 RTI Activists: inclips.net/video/zE_tnXDXlaI/वीडियो.html
    Ep 7 Ache Din in UP: inclips.net/video/dPvM2n2AFAw/वीडियो.html
    Ep 6 Lairs Modi, Ivanka: inclips.net/video/jt14K39g7Tw/वीडियो.html
    Ep 5 Padmavati: inclips.net/video/1M9XXdpuiaw/वीडियो.html
    Ep 4 Rajasthan: inclips.net/video/y26_c2jNPUw/वीडियो.html
    Ep 3 Jay Shah growth: inclips.net/video/FfTpWUPsdsc/वीडियो.html
    Ep 2 Indian economy: inclips.net/video/1ZIFEASmno0/वीडियो.html
    Ep 1 Currency Notes: inclips.net/video/sAH9YyR3O4c/वीडियो.html
    More videos:
    Rahul Gandhi vs Modi: inclips.net/video/Lem7KgAb9SY/वीडियो.html
    PayTM reality: inclips.net/video/cseroHjs__E/वीडियो.html
    Air Pollution: inclips.net/video/Yo_mO0L8uE4/वीडियो.html
    BJP IT Cell part 2: inclips.net/video/BslKjxaP4Ik/वीडियो.html
    Maun Modi: inclips.net/video/KOudMPiJFBI/वीडियो.html
    Indian Education: inclips.net/video/ABmXRhizz4I/वीडियो.html
    PNB Scam: inclips.net/video/5dL4AtHYd1w/वीडियो.html
    Bitcoin: inclips.net/video/Kesk8WK1uWM/वीडियो.html
    Aadhaar Card: inclips.net/video/S_bvQO6K5fY/वीडियो.html
    Best State in India: inclips.net/video/XPwVq56l1rk/वीडियो.html
    Petrol Prices reality: inclips.net/video/OSQXo3DpFAg/वीडियो.html
    Budget 2018: inclips.net/video/Ncjcg97P1Tg/वीडियो.html
    Save Our Forests: inclips.net/video/jHmXSpTVjZA/वीडियो.html
    ----------------------------------------------------

टिप्पणियाँ • 19 011

  • Dhruv Rathee
    Dhruv Rathee  5 महीने पहले +458

    Many people are questioning my assumption that SC/ST/OBC candidates don't compete with general candidates in open category seats. The reason for my assumption is simple. You must have seen often that even the reserved seats for SC, ST, OBC are lying vacant because there aren't enough candidates to fill them up. Here is a report which shows that OBCs just take up 12% of the jobs, far less than their reserved percentage. Same with SC/ST. Therefore, it is totally ok to assume that they were not really competing for the open category seats.
    Read: timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/20-years-after-Mandal-less-than-12-OBCs-in-central-govt-jobs/articleshow/50328073.cms

    • SUKHEN MOHANTA
      SUKHEN MOHANTA दिन पहले

      😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • Jyotiprakash Pati
      Jyotiprakash Pati 10 दिन पहले

      U really stupid..u might not get a chaprasi job

  • Mohit Sharma
    Mohit Sharma 19 घंटे पहले

    Is pr tum kuch nhi bol paoge bcz u have no answer

  • Mohit Sharma
    Mohit Sharma 19 घंटे पहले

    Kha mil rhi h
    Kha so rha h

  • Mohit Sharma
    Mohit Sharma 20 घंटे पहले

    90 percent Ko fayda lol
    N a big lol

  • Mohit Sharma
    Mohit Sharma 20 घंटे पहले

    Nhi Apne galat calculate Kiya h
    Thoda to improve kro pdhe likhe dikh rhe ho 60 percent logo k pas 100 sq feet home h

  • Mohit Sharma
    Mohit Sharma 20 घंटे पहले

    Max. Logo k 100sq. Foot h
    So bhut logo Ko milega
    ....

  • Saptaparno Sasmal
    Saptaparno Sasmal दिन पहले

    Bhai 10% increase kar ke usko reservation me rakha hain

  • SUKHEN MOHANTA
    SUKHEN MOHANTA दिन पहले

    Desh main 80% to hindu hi hai,

  • Surjit Singh
    Surjit Singh 2 दिन पहले

    Modi sarkar wasting time of parliament on unnecessary bill pl. focus on unemployed youths in the country

  • vishant rana
    vishant rana 3 दिन पहले

    I think jobs should only for those who are able.
    Reservation should be abolished.

  • Neha Sharma
    Neha Sharma 4 दिन पहले +1

    Ye video twit me hona chayehe so that pm modi can see

    • Jatin Singh
      Jatin Singh 4 दिन पहले

      Yes sis u r right

  • Abhishek Iratkar
    Abhishek Iratkar 6 दिन पहले

    You have only congrees agenda along with secularism but why don't you talk about triple talq bill which congrees are not support ....and why

  • RUMPA KHAMRAI
    RUMPA KHAMRAI 9 दिन पहले +1

    Ye bjp mantrio ne public ka itna paisa luta ki 8 lakh v bahut chhota amount hai in logon k samne

  • RUMPA KHAMRAI
    RUMPA KHAMRAI 9 दिन पहले +1

    10% reservation faltu hai, log itne bewakuf nahi hai.

  • mm shaikh ar shaikh
    mm shaikh ar shaikh 9 दिन पहले

    Neet form registration Karne ke liye open student ews me bhare ya open me form bahre. ...ews ka student open me ayega kiya ?

  • Dharmendra Singh
    Dharmendra Singh 11 दिन पहले

    lack of knowledge

  • Sameer Kadam
    Sameer Kadam 11 दिन पहले +4

    I sense you being motivated by political forces against Modi

  • gajraj rathi
    gajraj rathi 11 दिन पहले

    Tri problem BJP s h bhai 😂

  • Khushal Singh Rajput
    Khushal Singh Rajput 13 दिन पहले +1

    *Lollipop diya h modiya* 😬😬
    *Remove Reservation*

  • SUBRATA DEY
    SUBRATA DEY 13 दिन पहले

    Jindegi kaise chal raha hai?

  • Gautam Kumar Bose
    Gautam Kumar Bose 14 दिन पहले +1

    Pehele Research kar ke aao video banane se pehele...

  • Bhavya Saran
    Bhavya Saran 14 दिन पहले +8

    My lord you call your self journalist and you did your so called research and you don't even know about the basics of reservation...i feel bad for the people believing you

  • Explore incredible india In Hindi
    Explore incredible india In Hindi 15 दिन पहले

    Pure reservation ko hi khatam kar dena chaiye .

  • sushant patel
    sushant patel 16 दिन पहले +5

    Mr dhruv plz do ur homework...u don't know even 50% of this reservation .....how can u say that 80% peoples in this country are living at 500 squre fit
    ...
    .u don't know how much area cover in 1000 square fit

  • SUNIL PARIT
    SUNIL PARIT 17 दिन पहले

    You think like me

  • Sandeep Shrivastva
    Sandeep Shrivastva 17 दिन पहले

    Mai general se hun Mera officers sc hai aur Mai general se hun clerk , usse double knowledge Mai rakhta hun but Kya

  • Sheetalanil Sharma
    Sheetalanil Sharma 17 दिन पहले

    Pr pehle obc wale general ki kafo seat le lete the ab is 10% me nhi le payenge to minute sa difference pad Sakta h

  • gamer phantom
    gamer phantom 18 दिन पहले +1

    Sarkar ko bolo open Walon Ko reservation mat de par OBC aur SC walo ka reservation Hata De Is Se Sab ko hi fayda hoga Agar Kisi Garib bache Ke Paas talent hai to use paison se madad karo

  • gamer phantom
    gamer phantom 18 दिन पहले +1

    Baat mein Dum Tu Hai

  • Automation
    Automation 19 दिन पहले

    Ab data hame bata hai ki 🤣🤣🤣🤣 modi 🤬🤬🤬

  • Ashish Vashishth
    Ashish Vashishth 20 दिन पहले

    first time, very bad explanation, koi ni bhai isse pehle kaafi achi information bhi di h wo dete rho aap.
    and this is not jumla .
    u r 86% absolutely wrong.
    yes i checked this information and data many times

  • deepak sharma
    deepak sharma 20 दिन पहले

    Poorest analyst ever

  • Dhrmandar Chachal
    Dhrmandar Chachal 20 दिन पहले

    Bhaiya kya EWS category ki cut offs general sie km hogi kya plz reply bhaiya it's urgent to know me to feel my form

  • Sandhya Sharma
    Sandhya Sharma 21 दिन पहले +1

    Par seats bhi to 10% bhadhege

  • AAYUSH SAINI
    AAYUSH SAINI 21 दिन पहले

    75000 jobs is given by the government right this year

  • AAYUSH SAINI
    AAYUSH SAINI 21 दिन पहले +1

    Are pagal wo 10% pe SC ST OBC nahi aa sakte !!! Aur baaki 40% par aasakte hai jaise aate the to 10% pe sirf general aaye na...... tu mil bc debate kar kuch bhi bool rha hai

  • sandeep singh negi
    sandeep singh negi 22 दिन पहले +2

    Only making air for other party he is liar and also distrored facts

  • Rajender Gautam
    Rajender Gautam 22 दिन पहले

    Sir, himachal m EWS ka 4 lac income requirements kr di gye h kya yh Acha h

  • Zeba Mehbin
    Zeba Mehbin 23 दिन पहले

    I used to remember when i was in 9th we had to fill a paper for the cbse 10th registration..Many of the students have written fake amout in the column of annual income..most of the them written annual income as 56000 76000 and all even when they earn lakhs thinking that they will give you extra marks on the basis of income and caste 😂😂😂😂😂

  • Bhaskar PL
    Bhaskar PL 23 दिन पहले

    Misleading you all, his explanations are wrong, he is making real jumala
    He thinks we can fool the people..

  • HARSHITA SINHA MUSIC
    HARSHITA SINHA MUSIC 24 दिन पहले

    You are already poor
    Your video is of 9 January 2019
    And you mentioned 9 January 2018

  • Ritik Bhardwaj
    Ritik Bhardwaj 24 दिन पहले +4

    Sir 50000 PR month is no eligible to get admission in private medical College we don't want reservation but sir if someone got 560 someone gets 450 and got admission on government seat to sir we loose our confidence and from above data u tell who is more eligible

  • iam Indian
    iam Indian 25 दिन पहले

    8 lack per year, 85000 per month how can they poor

  • RV
    RV 27 दिन पहले

    Bhai kya bol Raha hai Bina sar paer ka... Open category me reserved candidates bhi fight karte hai .. so it makes difference qki ye new 10 percent exclusive hai jaha koi aur fight nhi karega.
    And govt talking about family income .you are comparing it with individual income.
    Get your basics checked buddy before spreading false News.
    Upar se ye jo criteria hai , wo ek Sath follow hona chahiye . Har criteria me bhale hi 80 percent log Ho Lekin wo Kam honge jo SAB criteria fulfill karte hai .
    To his subscribers, ye Bohot sare true facts k bich me 4-5 wrong and manipulative baate daal deta hai. He washes your brain and spreads hatred .

  • Mohan Singh
    Mohan Singh 29 दिन पहले +1

    Sirf criticize karne ke liye janm liye h tune aaj 27May h aur modi ek tarfa jita h.. Bhai ab to sudarja

  • prabhakar bhai
    prabhakar bhai 29 दिन पहले

    ध्रुव राठी भाई, आज के जमाने में किसी के बारे में बहुत ही नेगेटिव बात करना, अपना कड़ा स्वार्थ या षड्यंत्र माना जाता है. इससे सामने वाले का बहुत फायदा होता है
    कृपया अपना थोड़ा पैटर्न बदलिए.

  • Mukesh Kumar
    Mukesh Kumar महीने पहले +1

    Desh ko loot raha..hai

  • Mukesh Kumar
    Mukesh Kumar महीने पहले +1

    Sab chor hai...bhai

  • Sukhbeer Singh Dahiya
    Sukhbeer Singh Dahiya महीने पहले

    You are right bhai ji

  • rahul singh
    rahul singh महीने पहले +13

    sir ur analysis is wrong so please recheck your video

    • Bhavya Saran
      Bhavya Saran 14 दिन पहले

      Bro this dumbo does these type of bullshit analysis very often... remember what he said about the GDP growth formula change...he was lying knowingly or unknowingly i don't know...the formula change was in works from 2011 and the formula which is currently used is more acceptable globally

  • Akash Dhiman
    Akash Dhiman महीने पहले

    Your right eye is bigger than left?

  • PUBGmobile Epic Wins
    PUBGmobile Epic Wins महीने पहले

    Koi alag tarafh ka PRIME minister's chaiyeh

  • PUBGmobile Epic Wins
    PUBGmobile Epic Wins महीने पहले

    Modi hataoo desh bachaooo

  • Dev
    Dev महीने पहले

    भाई जी , नोकरी हैं कहाँ , सरकारी नोकरी सिर्फ 2℅ हैं, 98 ℅ प्राइवेट हैं, ओर प्राइवेट में कोई आरक्षण नही है, खामखा आरक्षण का हव्वा बनाया जा रहा है , कुछ जाति वादी लोग इस आरक्षण के झण्डे को ले कर चल रहे है ताकि उनकी राजनीति की दुकान बंद न हो जाय , कुछ सड़ी मानसिकता के लोग जो आज भी अपने को स्वर्ण समझते है दूसरे अपने जैसे आदमी को ही दलित बना देते है , उनका साथ देने में कसर नही छोड़ते,अरे भाई इंसान है वो भी जीने दो उन्हें भी

  • kumar madhan
    kumar madhan महीने पहले +4

    Students who score good marks should be given admission that's it!!! Lost my medical seat due to this.

    • NEET AIIMS JIPMER
      NEET AIIMS JIPMER 8 दिन पहले

      There is nothing for general

    • Purvesh Vyas
      Purvesh Vyas महीने पहले +1

      My situation
      Jee mains Cut off this year in percentile
      General 89
      Obc 74
      Sc. 54
      St. 44
      My result. 83
      My friend result ( belongs to sc 72)
      Hum dono saath main reh kr padhai kr te the indore main
      Dono ki financial condition bhi same
      Or dono main koi bhedbhaav nhi hai saath main khana pina
      Ab batao meri kya galti
      Iske kaaran to or difference aa jata he

  • Prîyañka PC R-yà
    Prîyañka PC R-yà महीने पहले

    *_uh r right sir i salute of uh_* 🙋🙋🙋🙋👌👌👌👌👍👍👍👍

  • Pure Learning
    Pure Learning महीने पहले +1

    Hey dhruv u r right

  • Rameshwar Lokare
    Rameshwar Lokare महीने पहले

    Teri q jal rahi he...!!!

  • Jantu Deb
    Jantu Deb महीने पहले

    Are bhai iss reservation ki bajhese education system barbad ho rha ahi... reservation se seat lke medical me ja rha hai...fir suru kor dega logo Ko marna..

  • ERL Tech
    ERL Tech महीने पहले

    Thankyou sir... you are best

  • Kuldeep Singh Rawat
    Kuldeep Singh Rawat महीने पहले

    Point.. But what can be done! Nothing,,

  • Khondker Rifat Hossain
    Khondker Rifat Hossain महीने पहले

    You are a nice guy. I wish I could play a positive role in society

  • Rn Suar
    Rn Suar महीने पहले

    Abe kisko kya Mila tera knu jalta he

  • Rn Suar
    Rn Suar महीने पहले

    Tu apana mu dhoke aa phele

  • Rn Suar
    Rn Suar महीने पहले

    You are the biggest ass hole in the world do you know that.....

  • anita singh
    anita singh महीने पहले +4

    THIS SHOWS THAT YOU DO NOT EVEN BASIC KNOWLEDGE OF RESERVATION

  • robin singh
    robin singh महीने पहले

    jumla hai finance minister bhi kahta hai

  • robin singh
    robin singh महीने पहले

    pakoda banao job hai n isme bhi reservation milega

  • robin singh
    robin singh महीने पहले

    vaah yaar dhruv sahi bola main abhi airforce main reservation k liye soch raha tha

  • PUNJABI RINGTONE
    PUNJABI RINGTONE महीने पहले

    you are right

  • akash singhal
    akash singhal महीने पहले

    Haha kamal ke ho, jis foundation me 90% log aa jate unka data aapke pass nhi h

  • Bipin kumar Nirala
    Bipin kumar Nirala महीने पहले

    Tum se bada berojgar kon hoga murkh baith ke bakwas krte ho ..

  • SHIVA JHA
    SHIVA JHA महीने पहले

    Sc st के नाम पे मुलायम सिंह के बच्चों को आरक्षण मिल सकती ह पर एक गरीब सवर्ण को नही ये ह इस देश का संविधान।
    ऐसी ही है तो आरक्षण हतादो और योग्यता के अनुसार नौकरी दो

  • Goutam Godala
    Goutam Godala महीने पहले

    Modi gareebi nahi hata rahe
    Wo gareebo ko hi hatana chaite hai
    Na rahega gareeb na hogi gareebi

  • Dip
    Dip महीने पहले +1

    No EWS reservation for Marathi people

  • Yash Sharma
    Yash Sharma महीने पहले +2

    But one having one condition but it not means they have satisfied second condition

  • vikas kumar
    vikas kumar महीने पहले

    I want to say only 1% rich people have 75% property of india..... That's not equal.. U can make a video on this topic.... Aur baki 99% people are...

    Main reason education and population..

    • vikas kumar
      vikas kumar महीने पहले

      Where are u work

    • vikas kumar
      vikas kumar महीने पहले

      Foreign media also help check our fact

    • vikas kumar
      vikas kumar महीने पहले

      @priyanka jagtap no we can use different types of newspaper, I different news channels, different types of magazines and past history about, background of any people, can help our facts

    • vikas kumar
      vikas kumar महीने पहले

      @priyanka jagtap dhruv sir smart he..... Girls blindly like him....

    • priyanka jagtap
      priyanka jagtap महीने पहले +1

      @vikas kumar yes sir... But I am telling you this man cam fool anyone. Even though I am well educated mechanical engineering. I started trust him blindly , Without checking facts... Anyways good to know that you are ready to check fact and ready to face truth. Because some peoples are become totally blind with dhruv sir,. Even I was one of them. 😂😂

  • vikas kumar
    vikas kumar महीने पहले

    Every year how many engineers paas out in india but they are without practical knowledge...... Koi bhi sector lo... Chaahe doctor, mba graduate,

  • vikas kumar
    vikas kumar महीने पहले

    40 carore young people in india.... We can make our own company,factory,manifctr, etc.... And bhut saare yuva educated he but unemployee he.... They are not talented.. Gov should train.... Them for own business

  • vikas kumar
    vikas kumar महीने पहले

    Where are jobs?????.... Only 1% gov job in india.. 99 % are private sector.... And most problems are population

  • SOURADEEP CHAKRABORTY
    SOURADEEP CHAKRABORTY महीने पहले +2

    Ek SC IAS officer k beta ko kaun sa social injustice mila hai.

  • Rk Gautam
    Rk Gautam महीने पहले +12

    Why don't you say that OBC reservation up to 8 lakhs is wrong and also SC/ST reservation for those whose income is above 8 lakhs is also wrong.

  • Rk Gautam
    Rk Gautam महीने पहले

    Than same principle applies to OBC

  • Alefiya Mustafa
    Alefiya Mustafa महीने पहले

    Bhai mujhe Bhi aisi laga par jee mains mein 1 lakh general rank laane wala Bande ko 12000 rank aara

  • deepak kumar
    deepak kumar महीने पहले

    Kya hme cutya smja hai kya sale

  • p.p anupama
    p.p anupama महीने पहले

    Hi sir, I follow ur channel most of time, and I appreciated about your work u r doing and making us aware about many thing but this time iam not agree with u sir.....Sir time has changed value of goods have increased, our basic need can't meet in this century...after launching such kind of good scheme till people are facing lack of vacancy in education and job...our most of youths are still employed..but I think this scheme is good for general category..but I think government have to do something for govt jobs like age limit of the govt services need to increase ..so people can take advantage of it..as u said job need to increase that is correct..but along with this iam with the scheme which is govt has took for general category..people r really poor it's not shocking abt this..

  • Stand Hub
    Stand Hub महीने पहले

    Chal nikal baap ko mat sikha

  • PARDEEP KUMAR
    PARDEEP KUMAR महीने पहले

    Sc, bc d marks equal krdo with general. Form fess la lo. Marks equal hone chide. Examples ugc net test.
    SC BC 50 percent
    GEN 60 ABOVE
    God give equal mind to human beings

  • Vijay Maneksha
    Vijay Maneksha महीने पहले

    Sahi hai. Ye politics desh ko kaha le ja Rahi hai

  • DESI DOST
    DESI DOST महीने पहले

    Bhag B dk

  • Sony Bhajans
    Sony Bhajans महीने पहले

    Reservation hatao... desh bachao...

  • Mousumi Biswas
    Mousumi Biswas महीने पहले

    Bilkul sahi

  • pokkiri mon
    pokkiri mon महीने पहले

    Who the bloody hell here have residential plot below 4 cent... im belong to general category and my residential plot is above 4 cent.. i went to village to apply for ews reservation, they said noone in kerala is going to get ews reservation 😂😂😂😂😂

  • LANDMARK CONSULTANCY
    LANDMARK CONSULTANCY महीने पहले

    Dhruv ji...
    Is video ko dekhne ke Baad mai yahi kahunga ki....
    Aapse jyada bewkuf youtuber sayad hi koi aur ho....

  • Raj Chik baraik
    Raj Chik baraik महीने पहले

    Please make a video on tea garden issues of west bengal, dooars tea garden plz plz plz

  • Shaurya Kanwar
    Shaurya Kanwar महीने पहले

    modi ki mkb mkc

  • Ashish Dubey
    Ashish Dubey महीने पहले

    I m waiting
    When will be reservation in Indian cricket team, ipl ,private companies, gold seller, vegetables seller,free lancer, president post,prime Minister post,chief minister post,mp post,mla post
    Govt providing reservation in govt sector only
    Govt should ask reservation in private companies for upliftment of backward caste people
    Vote for reservation only
    .............open candidate student

  • Rekha Agarwal
    Rekha Agarwal महीने पहले

    Bhai kya jobs jobs kar raha hai
    Sabko kya ghar jake jobs dega
    Aagar tumhare pas koi skill hi nahi hai to job kaha se milega
    🤬🤬

  • Shree Patil
    Shree Patil महीने पहले

    Sir I got 79 percentile in jee main and I have rand 24000 so can I get nit college

  • ROSE merry
    ROSE merry महीने पहले +1

    If young generation get jobs, how will politiantions get so large" BHEED" in rellies taking out flags in their hands?????????